2 users responded in this post

Subscribe to this post comment rss or trackback url
User Gravatar
charlie arehart said in March 27th, 2008 at 3:37 pm

Hey Rey, at the risk of becoming a lightning rod, I’ll add just one point of clarification: some have a beef not with being forced to use projects but rather being forced to open files from within the editor. They just prefer to open files from the file system directly, as in using Windows Explorer or My Computer on Windows (or when viewing the file system from within any other tool or its file>open dialog). This works fine if you’ve not yet opened Eclipse, but once opened, if you try it again it will launch an entirely new copy of Eclipse for that selected file. DW, HomeSite, and CF Studio (if configured to open CFM files) will, like most apps, just open them in a new window.

Many realize that this is a problem of Eclipse, not CFEclipse, and that there have been attempts over the years to resolve it.

And as you say, working in projects has its value–and some will puke on any with the temerity to complain of this issue of opening files from the file system (outside the editor). And yes, it may appear to some that opening files from the file system would indicate one’s not using source control, but that’s not necessarily the case. To those who’d want to argue against those with this beef, I’ll say “Dudes, chill”. Different strokes for different folks.

If it means some don’t use Eclipse for this reason, or don’t use it as their default editor, it will be their loss. If you really want to convert them, focus instead on helping them appreciate all the many other reasons to use Eclipse/CFEclipse which can’t be found in DW/HS/CFS.

I realize that was Rey’s goal here. Just saying that it addresses one problem (using the File Explorer within Eclipse), just sadly not this other one, which may be as big a problem for many holdouts. :-) (If I’m wrong, and this fix does indeed solve that too, I’ll be the first to shout Halleluiah from the rooftops!)

User Gravatar
charlie arehart said in March 27th, 2008 at 3:38 pm

Sorry, should have addressed this to Jake, not “Rey”. Caught that *just* after sending. Doh! :-)

Leave A Reply

 Username (Required)

 Email Address (Remains Private)

 Website (Optional)